NYX Cosmetics Free 2-Piece Gift Set w/ $35+ SHOP NOW
Sulwhasoo Free Shipping + Samples All Orders SHOP NOW
e.l.f. cosmetics 25% OFF Orders $35+ SHOP NOW

So I got sick of Googling comparison swatches for the Target Laneige Medium vs Laneige Pore Control Shade 31 and not finding anything; ...

So I got sick of Googling comparison swatches for the Target Laneige Medium vs Laneige Pore Control Shade 31 and not finding anything; so I did what any other sane person would do:  Buy all of them and swatch them so you don't have to!  PLUS a bonus Laneige Anti-Aging Shade 31 Swatch just for fun!  

Laneige BB Cushion (U.S. Target Version) Shade Medium
VS Laneige Pore Control BB Cushion Shade 31
VS Laneige Anti-Aging BB Cushion Shade 31

My wallet.  It hurts.

INFO SHEET

Brand:  Laneige
Product:  BB Cushion (Target Edition)
Shade:  Medium
Coverage:  Light - Medium
Dewiness:  Very Dewy
Scent:  Strong, Floral Potpourri - Just like Grandma's house.
Oxidation:  Slight
Price:  $34.00
Availability:  Target in Select Stores and Online

The Run Down:  
P.S. I already reviewed this cushion in another post!

  • Great match for NC37
  • Potent Grandma scent for the first 1-2 hours of wear
  • VERY Dewy
  • Not good for Combination / Oily Skin



Brand:  Laneige
Product:  Pore-Control BB Cushion
Shade:  31
Coverage:  Light - Medium
Dewiness:  Slightly Dewy
Scent:  Fresh Floral with Notes of Grandma's House
Oxidation:  More than Slight
Price:  $50.00
Availability:  YesStyle.com

The Run Down:

  • Better match for NC30 - NC35
  • Scent lingers for the first 1 - 2 hours of wear.
  • Slightly Dewy
  • Better for Combination / Oily Skin



Brand:  Laneige
Product:  Anti-Aging BB Cushion
Shade:  31
Coverage:  Light - Medium
Dewiness:  Semi-Dewy
Scent:  Strong, Floral Potpourri - Just like Grandma's house.
Oxidation:  More than Slight
Price:  $50.00
Availability:  YesStyle.com

The Run Down:

  • Better match for NC35
  • Potent Grandma scent for the first 1-2 hours of wear
  • Dewy at first, but dries to Semi-Dewy
  • Better for Dry / Aging Skin



COMPARISON SWATCH

Laneige Target Medium does NOT match Laneige Shade # 31


I was surprised by a few things:  Target Laneige Medium does NOT match Laneige Pore Control / Anti-Aging cushions in Shade 31.  It is in fact a bit darker and slightly warmer.  I was also surprised that the Laneige Pore Control cushion is actually a little lighter than Laneige Anti-Aging cushion of the same shade.  I had always read that the Anti-Aging cushion was supposed lighter because it's meant to give you a brighter, youthful glow.  However, it is not lighter than the Pore Control cushion.

Ironically enough, the IOPE Air Cushion XP in Shade 31 is a lot closer in shade to Target Laneige Medium, but the IOPE Air Cushion XP in 31 is a little more pink.  It is kind of annoying that the 31 shades can vary so greatly for companies which are all under the Amore Pacific umbrella.  I am really hoping that the Sulwhasoo Perfecting Cushion Brightening in shade 33 is closer to IOPE's shade 31...  At any rate, I have swatched all of the cushions I own:  See cushion swatch comparison list below!

I think the best match for NC37 out of the three Laneige Cushions is the Target Laneige Medium BB Cushion.  It has a nice, neutral and slightly warm tone which blends easily.  It also does not seem to oxidize much at all.  Another thing that I like about it is that it is readily available for purchase in the U.S.  However, as per my previous review; it is simply too dewy to be used on combination / oily skin.  This was the biggest caveat for me.  If it wasn't so dewy I would continue to purchase it and even put up with the scent.  In the end, I wish they would just make a semi-dewy or semi-matte version of the Target Laneige BB Cushion (pretty please?).

The Laneige Pore Control BB Cushion in Shade 31 is an okay fit for NC37, especially after oxidation.  It does not oxidize a lot but the color does neutralize enough so that it is not as bright as when first applied.  I feel that it may be a better match for someone who is NC30 - NC35.  NC37's can wear it if blended and used for lighter coverage, but not good for higher coverage applications.

And finally, this brings us to the Laneige Anti-Aging BB Cushion in Shade 31.  It is is in the same boat as the Pore Control as it is a bit lighter than the Target Laneige Medium.  If you look closely though, you will notice that it is a little darker and just a hair more pink than the Pore Control, and it may be better suited for NC35.  The color is an okay fit for NC37 looking for lighter coverage.  It is okay for use on combination skin (but not oily).  You may still need to blot your t-zone though.

A note on the Laneige cushion cases:  Laneige Pore Control and Anti-Aging cushion refills do fit into each other's cases.  These cases are also a little more compact when compared to the Target Laneige cushion case; which is larger and bulkier.  Since the Laneige Target version is larger, the refills do not fit into the Pore Control / Anti-Aging cases (vice versa).


FINAL THOUGHTS

I will continue to purchase the Laneige Pore Control BB Cushion in shade 31 as long as YesStyle continues to stock it.  I would even opt for the Anti-Aging cushion of the same shade if for some reason the Pore Control is unavailable.  It is very difficult to find cushions in these shades online.  Even now YesStyle is out of stock on all shade 31 Laneige Cushions.  So if that is the case... the search continues.


SWATCH COMPARISON LIST

For reference and for science!


Master Swatch List

In Chizu Saeki's book The Japanese Skincare Revolution , she states that excessive skincare damages the skin.  She goes on to recommend ...

In Chizu Saeki's book The Japanese Skincare Revolution, she states that excessive skincare damages the skin.  She goes on to recommend "skin fasting" which basically means do not do anything for one day out of the week.  Don't wear makeup, do not put absolutely anything on your skin save for rinsing it with water.

The Skincare Diet and the Art of Listening to Your Skin

Left:  Damaged skin with Acne, Right:  A year and a half later.

This scared me.

But she has a great point.  I had been struggling with painful, itchy acne and bumpy skin for a long time and while my routine had good products in it; I was still breaking out.  So I thought it was time to go on a diet, a Skincare Diet.

I was going to follow Saeki's advice but I still wanted to wash my face because my skin is oily.  I decided that I was going to slim down my routine and only use my trusted Cerave Foaming Cleanser and Benton Snail Bee Steam Cream.  Cerave Foaming Cleanser is a gentle, low PH cleanser that doesn't strip your skin.  If your cleanser leaves your skin feeling tight then that is not good!  That means your skin was stripped of it's natural oils and barrier.  Benton Snail Bee Stream Cream is moisturizing, mild and soothing for me.  I figured if I was still breaking out then one of these products may be the culprit.  Luckily for me, they weren't.

After two weeks of dieting, my skin no longer itched and was no longer in pain.  I still had acne but I realized that I was doing something right.  This is how I learned to listen to my skin.

All along, my skin was telling me something was wrong!  It was clearly upset and I wasn't listening.  I was putting stuff on my skin that it did not like but I thought would help.  So over the next few weeks, I was determined to find out what that was.  I decided that the next item to try from my original routine would be Tarte Maracuja Oil.  I put two drops on my skin once every three days, and that's when the itchiness returned.  Cross that off the list.  I tried it and my skin said "Nope, try again." This sucked because I had just purchased a very large, expensive and most luxurious bottle of this stuff; which Ulta so graciously let me return.  You guys, the bottle was so beautiful and encrusted with gems (holiday edition).  I really didn't want to give it up, but my skin told me that I must let it go.

Through this process, my skin also told me that it does not like Glycolic acid.  Even in very small doses, it ranted in the form of acne and pain.  I had always patch tested before but I did not understand the subtleties of what my skin was telling me until it was too late.  In the end I thought I was purging, but purging shouldn't be itchy and inflamed!  This time, I listened.

Now when I want to try a new product, I have a process that I follow.  For example, I wanted to stop using Paula's Choice BHA Liquid because I did not see any results from using it for a few months.  I decided that I wanted to replace it with COSRX BHA Blackhead Power liquid.

I patch tested in two areas:  1) My Chin - Where I do not break out, and 2)  My Right Cheek - Where I break out quite easily.  My skin's response:  Two very large zits on my right cheek (these are now the two spots on my cheek you see pictured above).  It was angry, but the flare up occurred in a location where I would normally break out.  I deduced that the product was working as intended by bringing a would-be zit to head, but I needed to scale it back.  I now apply only 3 - 4 drops once a week on damp skin as I originally tried it on dry.  Since then, I haven't gotten any zits and even the occasional hormonal acne I would normally get also ceased.

Another example is that I wanted to try out Kikumasamune High Moist Lotion with the intention of using it for Chizu Saeki's Lotion Mask technique.  I used the same testing process as above.  My skin's response:  a few very tiny whiteheads on my cheek that rubbed away when I washed my face.  I translated this as "This is okay, but I need time to get used to it."  I now use it for the Lotion Mask technique, but only a few drops once a week.  In the lotion mask technique, you wet the cotton square on the back of your hand with distilled water and press out the excess water.  You then apply the hydrating toner of your choice, separate the cotton, and place on your face for three minutes as a sort of make shift sheet mask.  Since my skin told me it needed time, I only did this once a week with maybe eight drops of Kikumasamune (which is diluted in the wet cotton) and slowly increasing the dosage over a few weeks. Now my skin does not react with the little white heads, and I get to experience the joy of soft hydration that Kikumasamune High Moist Lotion and sheet masking can provide.  I don't sheet mask at all otherwise, because you can't patch test a sheet mask :(.

One thing to remember is that everyone is different.  What works for others may not work for you.  I thought Tarte Maracuja Oil was probably the most gentle thing I could use, but my skin did not like it.  Just like our food, some people can eat oranges and some people can't (I can't - acid sensitivity) even though oranges are good for you!

So there you have it.  The trick is to listen, wait, and be patient.  Don't haul and shock your skin with a bunch of random stuff.  Imagine how your stomach would react by dramatically changing your diet suddenly?  Your skin is no different.  Give it time and be gentle.

Search This Blog

Powered by Blogger.